How To Register As A National Securities Exchange With The Sec

May 04, 2022

Environmental Enforcement, Suspension, and Debarment with Robert... by: Daniel J. Pope and Robert J. Wagman, Jr.
The Terminate of Red china Tariffs? USTR 4-Year Review on the Horizon by: David R. Hamill and Leah Scarpelli
Eu, Great britain Propose New Sanctions Against Russian federation,... past: Raminta Dereskeviciute and Ludovica Rabitti
What'due south New in 5G - May 2022 by: Angela Y. Kung and Christen B'anca Glenn
SEC Proposes New Rules in Response to GameStop Trading and Related... past: Katherine M. Devlin
DOE Announces Over $iii Billion in Funding Opportunities to Back up U.S... past: Joel Meister and R. Lynn Parins
Commerce Clarifies Telescopic of CSPV Circumvention Enquiry and Provides... by: Carl J. Fleming and Lynn K. Kamarck
USCIS Increases Automated Extension Period of Employment... past: Juan S. Steevens
Spring Cleaning: CFPB Dusts Off "Dormant" Authority to Supervise "... by: Rachel Rodman and Wesley Wintermyer
How to Inspect Your Past Marketing Efforts past: Meranda M. Vieyra
New USCIS Dominion Automatically Extends Some Noncitizens' Work Permits... by: Jennifer Cory and Susan Waller Ramos
Can a Land Require a Corporation to Consent to General Personal... by: Hudson M. Stoner and David A. Fusco
The FCC's New Broadband Data Collection is About to Launch by: Sean Stokes and Kathleen Slattery Thompson
Final Medicare Advantage and Part D Rule will Likely Require Medicare... by: Bridgette A. Keller and Lauren M. Moldawer
Changes to Rule 702 Cement Judge'due south Role as Gatekeeper for Expert... by: Timothy E. Burroughs
Attorney-Customer Privilege Issues: Three Ways Companies Tin Shield... by: Kirstie Brenson and Adam Diederich
USCIS Temporarily Increases Automatic Extension Menses for Certain... by: Katherine C. MacIlwaine
Electric Mobility Canada on Its Promises for a Cleaner Economic system [... by: Birgit Matthiesen
Two States Enact Insurance Information Security Laws by: Hunton Andrews Kurth's Privacy and Cybersecurity
FTC Proposes Updates to Telemarketing Sales Dominion, Business to... by: Moorari Shah and A.J. South. Dhaliwal
Is Mexico Winning Reshoring? by: Jeffrey A. Soble
Ohio Significantly Changes Real Belongings Tax Valuation Procedures,... by: Jonathan T. Brollier
Hydrogen Rising: Tracing Your Origins, a Conversation With... by: David L. Wochner
From Cryptic to (some) Clarity: English language Police force and Policy Rising to the... past: Steven Bakery and Julia Bihary
NYC Pay Transparency Law, Florida Diversity Training, and Cal/OSHA's... by: Employment, Labor, Workforce Management Epstein Becker Green
New Labour Codes in Republic of india Delayed by: P Vivek Ilawat and Sayantani Saha
Emotional Distress Damages Non Bachelor in Private Rehabilitation... past: Henry Morris, Jr.
Financial Regulation, Monetary Policy and the Metaverse past: Richard J. Krainin and Jerome Shuman Jr.
For These Directors, In that location May Be No Way Out past: Keith Paul Bishop
Connecticut is on the Privacy Movement by: Christopher J. Buontempo and Cynthia J. Larose
SEC's Partition of Examinations Issues Risk Alert on Investment... by: Keri Due east. Riemer and Wilhelm P. Dietz
Earth Day Serial 2022: Environmental, Social & Governance Office 3... by: William Due south. "Buddy" Cox Three
The Expanding Landscape of Alcohol Delivery Services by: Alva C. Mather
Who Appoints the Arbitral Tribunal Under the SIAC Rules by: Ashish Kabra and Vyapak Desai
Even Indirect Income from Cannabis Can Get You Banned From Bankruptcy by: Lance P. Martin and Tyler J. Russell
Proposed Updates to Qualified Opportunity Zone (QOZ) Rules by: Katherine Due east. Cole and S. Katherine Frazier
Third Circuit Problems Order in WaWa Information Breach by: Shing Tse and Kristin 50. Bryan
CA Appellate Court Addresses "Willfulness" Standard Under FCRA past: Steven J Pearlman and Edward C. Young
Canada Publishes Dietary Guidelines Resources past: Food and Drug Police at Keller and Heckman
US States Charge Into the Hereafter with Federal Support for EV Charging... by: ScheLeese Goudy
Connecticut Likely to Become 5th Country to Enact Comprehensive... by: Joseph J. Lazzarotti and Jason C. Gavejian
Illinois Department of Labor Publishes Guidance for Employers Seeking... past: Steven J Pearlman and Edward C. Young
DHS Increases Automatic Extension of Work Authorizations for Sure... past: Michael H. Neifach and Amy L. Peck
PFAS CERCLA Exemptions Lobbying Increases by: John Gardella
Your Employee As Your Arbitrator? Maybe! by: Sahil Kanuga and Vyapak Desai
DHS Extends I-9 Compliance Flexibility past: Mark Wu
Dairy, LLC v. Milk Moovement, Inc.: Identifying Software Trade... by: Amanda B. Zemel
The Bottom Line of the SEC Proposed Individual Fund Rules by: Howard J Beber and Michael F Mavrides
DOJ Settles Immigration Discrimination Claim Confronting Washington Home... by: Raymond G. Lahoud
FERC Proposes Reforms to Transmission Planning and Cost Allocation;... past: Eric 50. Christensen
Interim Protection Bachelor Only Confronting the "Fruits" of The... by: Alipak Banerjee and Vyapak Desai

SEC BlockFi Settlement Signals Crypto Lending Platforms to Comply with Federal Securities Law

On February 14, 2022, the U.S. Securities and Substitution Commission (SEC) entered a consent order (the Order) against BlockFi Lending LLC.(one) In the novel activity, the SEC found that BlockFi failed to register the offers and sales of a crypto lending product, BlockFi Interest Accounts (BIAs). The Order establish that this carry violated the registration and antifraud provisions of the Securities Act and the Investment Company Deed of 1940. In order to settle the matter, BlockFi agreed to pay a $fifty meg civil penalty and cease its unregistered offers and sales of the BIAs.

BlockFi Interest Accounts and the Order

The SEC'southward investigation focused on BlockFi'due south BIAs, lending products that immune investors to lend their crypto assets to BlockFi in exchange for monthly interest payments. The monthly interest payment varied, but BlockFi offered interest rates as high as nine percentage on digital assets deposited into the BIAs. On its website, BlockFi represented that the borrowed digital assets were then being lent to institutional investors or invested in "SEC-regulated equities and predominantly CFTC-regulated futures," which offered a mutually benign return for BlockFi and investors. The Guild stated that BlockFi "pooled the loaned assets, and exercised total discretion over how much to hold, lend, and invest. BlockFi had complete legal ownership and control over the loaned crypto assets, and advertised that it managed the risks involved."

According to the Order, the BIAs were unregistered securities and constituted investment contracts under the Howey and Reves tests. The iv-function Howey examination is the foundational examination for interpreting whether a production is subject to registration as a security, and it requires (1) the investment of coin; (2) in a mutual enterprise; (3) with an expectation of profits; (iv) derived solely through the efforts of others. In the Order, the SEC too applied the Reves test when considering whether the digital asset lending product is a "annotation" requiring registration. In Reves v. Ernst & Immature, the Supreme Court of the United States (the "Supreme Court") rejected the Howey test for analyzing notes. Instead, the Supreme Court applied a 2-stride analysis to decide whether a financial production was a "note" that was field of study to registration. The Supreme Courtroom starting time looked at whether the financial production was exempt from registration by examining judicially created categories previously exempted. If the fiscal product was not exempted, the Supreme Court considered iv factors to make up one's mind whether the product had a stiff "family unit resemblance" to a judicially created exemption: The Supreme Court considered (i) the motivation for entering the transaction; (2) the distribution plan; (3) the investing public'due south reasonable expectations; and (4) whether whatever chance-reducing factors existed that rendered application of the securities laws unnecessary.

Applying the Howey and Reves tests, the SEC institute that BlockFi offered BIAs as both "investment contracts" and "notes."(two) The SEC stated that BlockFi allowed investors to invest their digital avails in a BIA, and investors could reasonably expect to profit from such investment.(three) The SEC adamant that this arrangement satisfied the Howey examination.(4) Further, the SEC considered BIAs to be "notes" satisfying the Reves test considering the BIAs generated revenue for BlockFi through its lending and investment activities, and they were offered to the investing public.(five) Also, in that location were no other risk-reducing factors, such as another law or regulation protecting investors, that would render the application of the securities laws unnecessary.(6) As such, the SEC determined that the BIAs were notes and therefore securities.

Touch on of the SEC Lodge

The BlockFi settlement appears to provide sought-afterwards regulatory guidance in a burgeoning manufacture. For example, BlockFi CEO Zac Prince stated that, in accordance with the new regulatory clarity, the company intends to offer an "SEC-registered crypto interest bearing security, which volition let clients to earn interest on their crypto assets."(vii) In a printing release accompanying the Order, Director of the SEC's Division of Enforcement, Gurbir S. Grewal, stated that crypto manufacture participants "should take immediate find of today's resolution and come up into compliance with the federal securities laws."(8)

FOOTNOTES

SEC Order, Admin. Proc. No. 3-20758, at 2 (February. 14, 2022), available at https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2022/33-11029.pdf.
SEC Order, Admin. Proc. No. 3-20758, at 2.
Id. at viii.
Id.
Id.
Id.
Kollen Postal service and Frank Chapparo, With $100 one thousand thousand settlement confirmed, BlockFi aims to register Yield with SEC, The Block (Feb. 14, 2022), available at https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/134165/with-100-million-settlement-confirmed-blockfi-aims-to-register-yield-with-sec.
Printing Release, U.South. Secs. & Exch. Comm'due north, BlockFi Agrees to Pay $100 Million in Penalties and Pursue Registration of its Crypto Lending Product (Feb. 14, 2022), bachelor at https://world wide web.sec.gov/news/pressrelease/2022-26.

Printer-friendly
Email this Article
Download PDF
REPRINTS & PERMISSIONS

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Samuel M. Deau Associate Vedder Price

Samuel Thousand. Deau is an Associate* in Vedder Price's Chicago office and a member of the firm's Government Investigations & White Collar Defence force grouping.

Mr. Deau focuses his exercise on white collar criminal defense, internal investigations, and securities litigation. His experience includes representing individuals and corporations across different industries in complex matters involving the Department of Justice (DOJ), the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC), the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and other government agencies. Mr. Deau also...